Arrested for Petit Larceny in New York? Here’s What You Need to Know

If you were arrested, charged, or received a Desk Appearance Ticket for petit larceny or shoplifting in New York, you are facing a criminal charge — not a simple violation. Understanding what that means for your record, your job, and your future is critical before your first court date.

What Is Petit Larceny in New York?

Under New York Penal Law § 155.25, a person commits petit larceny when they steal property valued at less than $1,000. It is a Class A Misdemeanor — a crime — and a conviction creates a permanent criminal record.

The charge most commonly arises from shoplifting, but it also covers theft of cash, personal property, or anything else of value under the $1,000 threshold. Once the value reaches $1,000 or more, the charge becomes Grand Larceny — a felony.

Penalties for a Petit Larceny Conviction

A conviction under PL § 155.25 can result in:

• Up to 364 days in jail — New York law sets the maximum at 364 days, not a full year. This one-day difference is intentional and matters significantly for immigration purposes, as a sentence of one year or more can trigger federal deportation consequences for non-citizens
• Up to 3 years of probation
• Fines of up to $1,000, plus mandatory court surcharges
• Restitution — you may be required to repay the value of the stolen property
• A permanent criminal record that appears on background checks

In addition, the store or retailer can pursue a separate civil claim against you. Under New York law, civil recovery can include the retail price of the merchandise (if not returned in sellable condition), plus a civil penalty of the greater of five times the retail price or $75 — with the penalty portion capped at $500. Total civil exposure can reach up to $1,500. This civil action is separate from and independent of the criminal case.

What Happens After an Arrest

After a petit larceny arrest, you will typically be:

1. Detained, fingerprinted, and processed at a police precinct
2. Transported to criminal court for arraignment — usually the same day or the next morning
3. In some cases, released with a Desk Appearance Ticket (DAT) to appear in court at a later date rather than being held overnight

Even if you receive a DAT, you must appear in court on the date specified. Failure to appear will result in a warrant for your arrest.

One important note: a DAT typically charges you with one offense. However, when you appear in court, prosecutors may add additional charges — including Criminal Possession of Stolen Property in the Fifth Degree (PL § 165.40) — based on the same conduct. This means you could face two separate Class A misdemeanor charges from a single shoplifting incident.

Immigration Consequences of a Petit Larceny Charge

For anyone who is not a United States citizen, a petit larceny charge — and especially a conviction — carries immigration consequences that can be far more serious than the criminal penalties themselves. This applies to green card holders, visa holders, people with pending immigration applications, DACA recipients, asylum seekers, and anyone in the United States without legal status.

Petit larceny under New York Penal Law § 155.25 is widely considered a Crime Involving Moral Turpitude (CIMT) under federal immigration law. A CIMT is a category of offense that federal immigration authorities treat as reflecting serious moral misconduct, regardless of how the charge is classified under state law. The consequences of a CIMT conviction can include deportation or removal from the United States, being found inadmissible when applying for a visa, green card, or reentry into the country, denial of naturalization or citizenship applications, and loss of asylum or refugee protections in certain circumstances.

What makes petit larceny particularly dangerous for non-citizens is that even a misdemeanor conviction — not a felony — can trigger these consequences. A person who has lived in the United States for decades, holds a green card, has a family here, and has no other criminal history can face deportation based on a single petit larceny conviction. Immigration judges in some circumstances have very limited discretion to consider the full picture when a CIMT conviction is involved, which is why the outcome of the criminal case itself is so important.

The arrest record also matters. Even if the criminal case is ultimately dismissed, an arrest for petit larceny creates a permanent record that can appear in immigration background checks and must be disclosed on many immigration applications. Failing to disclose an arrest — even one that was dismissed — can itself be grounds for denial or other adverse action. This is why the manner in which a case is resolved is just as important as the resolution itself. An Adjournment in Contemplation of Dismissal (ACD), once sealed, is generally a better immigration outcome than a disorderly conduct plea, which is technically a conviction of record even though it is not a crime. A straight dismissal or declined prosecution is typically the strongest outcome from an immigration standpoint.

For non-citizens, it is critical that the defense attorney handling the criminal case understands immigration law, or works closely with immigration counsel, so that the resolution of the criminal case is structured in a way that minimizes immigration consequences. A plea that looks favorable from a purely criminal law perspective may carry serious immigration risks. Our firm regularly handles cases involving non-citizen clients and understands how to pursue resolutions that protect both the criminal record and the immigration status of our clients.

If you are not a U.S. citizen and you have been arrested or charged with petit larceny in New York, do not resolve your case without first consulting with an attorney who understands the immigration consequences of each possible outcome.

Consequences Beyond the Criminal Case

Many people focus only on jail time and fines — but for many clients, the collateral consequences of a petit larceny arrest are just as serious:

Professional licenses: An arrest — not just a conviction — can trigger an automatic suspension of licenses issued by state or city agencies. This includes HHA (home health aide) licenses, TLC (Taxi and Limousine Commission) licenses, security guard licenses, and others. These suspensions take effect during the pendency of the case and may be reinstated or permanently revoked depending on the outcome.

Employment: A criminal record for theft can disqualify you from jobs that require background checks — which includes most jobs in healthcare, finance, education, and government.

How Petit Larceny Cases Can Be Resolved

Depending on the facts, your background, and the specific circumstances of the case, petit larceny charges can be resolved in a number of ways — many of which avoid a criminal conviction entirely:

• Declined prosecution — the DA’s office declines to prosecute and the case is dismissed at arraignment
• Straight dismissal — charges are dismissed outright
• ACD (Adjournment in Contemplation of Dismissal) — the case is adjourned; if you stay out of trouble for a set period (typically 6 months), the case is dismissed and sealed under CPL § 170.55
• Disorderly conduct — a reduction to a non-criminal violation under PL § 240.20, which does not result in a criminal conviction, though it may still carry some immigration implications
• Conditional discharge — you avoid jail but the conviction is on record; conditions may include staying out of trouble and paying restitution

The right outcome depends on your prior record, the value of the alleged theft, the specific court, and the facts of the case. An experienced New York petit larceny attorney will know what is achievable in each jurisdiction and how to pursue the best possible result.

Key Defenses to Petit Larceny Charges

A petit larceny charge is not automatically a conviction. Larceny requires intent to steal — and the prosecution must prove it beyond a reasonable doubt. Common defenses include:

• Never left the store — Under New York law, the crime of petit larceny is not complete until you exit the premises with unpaid merchandise. If you were stopped by loss prevention inside the store before leaving, this may be a valid defense
• Lack of intent — If you accidentally walked out without paying — distracted, on the phone, or simply forgot — that is not theft. Mistakes are not crimes
• Claim of right — If you genuinely believed the property was yours or that you had a right to it, this can be a defense
• Mistaken identity — Store surveillance footage is not always clear; identity can be contested
• Insufficient evidence — The prosecution bears the burden of proof; weak or inconsistent evidence can result in dismissal

Do Not Give a Statement — to Anyone

If you are stopped by store security or loss prevention before police arrive, do not sign any statement or confession. Loss prevention personnel are not police officers, and Miranda warnings do not apply during their questioning — but anything you sign or say can be used as evidence against you in court.

Stay calm, stay silent, and contact a lawyer.

Where Petit Larceny Cases Are Prosecuted in New York

Cases in Nassau and Suffolk Counties may also be prosecuted in local village or town courts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is shoplifting the same as petit larceny in New York? Yes. Shoplifting is prosecuted as petit larceny under PL § 155.25 when the value of the merchandise is under $1,000. There is no separate shoplifting statute in New York.

Will a petit larceny charge show up on a background check? An arrest record is visible on background checks even without a conviction. A full dismissal or ACD — once sealed — significantly reduces this risk. An attorney can advise you on the best outcome for your specific situation.

What if I was stopped inside the store and never left? This is a meaningful legal issue. The crime of petit larceny generally requires that you exit the premises with the unpaid merchandise. Being stopped before you left the store may be a basis for dismissal or a strong defense at trial.

I am not a U.S. citizen. Can a petit larceny arrest affect my immigration status? Yes, and potentially very seriously. Petit larceny is considered a Crime Involving Moral Turpitude under federal immigration law, which can lead to deportation, inadmissibility, or denial of immigration benefits — even for green card holders with no other criminal history. The way your case is resolved matters as much as the resolution itself. Do not plead to anything without first consulting an attorney who understands the immigration consequences.

Can I handle a petit larceny charge without a lawyer? Given the potential consequences — criminal record, license suspension, immigration impact — it is strongly inadvisable. A defense attorney can often secure outcomes that a person representing themselves cannot, including dismissals and non-criminal resolutions.

Contact Sharifov & Associates, PLLC

If you have been arrested, charged, or received a Desk Appearance Ticket for petit larceny or shoplifting in New York City or Nassau County, call us for a free confidential consultation. We represent clients in Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan, the Bronx, Staten Island, Nassau County, and Suffolk County.

☎ 718-368-2800 (NYC / Brooklyn) ☎ 516-505-2300 (Long Island / Nassau County) ☎ 1-888-LAW-2407

Available 24/7. Former New York Prosecutor. Rated by Super Lawyers. 23+ years of experience.

Attorney Advertising. This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. The outcome of any case depends on the specific facts and circumstances involved.